Contents

How Do I Write a Goodwill Letter to Remove a Closed Account?

Written, Reviewed and Fact-Checked by The Credit People

Key Takeaway

To remove a closed account from your credit report, write a goodwill letter that is direct, respectful, and concise
clearly state the account, own your mistake, and explain your unique situation with evidence of improvement.
Target a decision-maker, not generic support, and highlight this was a one-time event, not a pattern.
Check your credit report from all three bureaus first to confirm and cite specific details.
Approval is never guaranteed, but a well-written letter boosts your chances for removal.

Let's fix your credit and raise your score

See how we can improve your credit by 50-100+ pts (average). We'll pull your score + review your credit report over the phone together (100% free).

 9 Experts Available Right Now

Call 866-382-3410

54 agents currently helping others with their credit

image

What Is A Goodwill Letter?

A goodwill letter is a formal request you send to a creditor asking them to remove negative but accurate information, like a late payment or a closed account, from your credit report out of kindness - not because they have to. It's basically an appeal to their sense of fairness, especially if you've generally been responsible or faced a one-off issue.

You want to clearly explain why the negative mark happened, take responsibility if needed, and mention any steps you've taken to avoid it again. The tone matters - keep it polite and professional to improve your chances. Remember, creditors can say no without any obligation to help.

This letter works best for minor slip-ups or unusual situations, like a medical emergency, rather than repeated problems. When done right, it might improve your credit score and give you a fresh start.

If you're wondering how to actually write one or what to include, check out 'what to include in your goodwill letter' next - it's super useful for making your letter compelling and clear.

Can Goodwill Letters Remove Closed Accounts?

Goodwill letters can sometimes get closed accounts removed, but it's not a guarantee - creditors aren't required to do it. They might be willing if the closed account is accurately reported but seriously hurting your score and you've got a solid history with them. It all comes down to their policies and how convincing your letter is. Explain your situation, own up where needed, and politely ask if they'd consider removing the record as a courtesy.

If the closed account has inaccuracies, a goodwill letter could help by nudging them to fix errors or remove the account. But if the account is accurate and was closed properly, removal is less common. Still, some creditors do make exceptions, especially if you faced hardships like medical emergencies or identity theft. Your chance improves if you can show you've since handled your finances responsibly.

When writing your goodwill letter, be clear and concise. Include details like the account name, dates, and reasons why removal would help your credit. Keep the tone respectful and thank them for considering your request. Avoid sounding demanding - that just shuts doors. Also, choose the right person or department to send the letter to, typically the creditor who reported the account.

Bottom line: goodwill letters can help remove closed accounts, but often only with goodwill and proof of your good faith. If this sounds like what you need, check out '5 situations when a goodwill letter works best' next for tips on maximizing your chances.

5 Situations When A Goodwill Letter Works Best

A goodwill letter works best in specific, targeted situations where your request feels fair and justified. First, it's ideal if you've made a one-off late payment but have otherwise managed the account flawlessly. Creditors often appreciate honesty and consistency, so highlighting your good history increases your chances. Think of it like saying, 'Hey, I usually pay on time, this was a slip-up.'

Next, if your negative mark stems from an unusual event - like a medical emergency or temporary financial hardship - explaining this context can sway a creditor's empathy. Make it clear these problems are behind you and you're back on solid ground. They want to see you're responsible despite a hiccup.

Another perfect moment for goodwill letters is when blemishes are older, nearing the time they drop off your credit report anyway. Since the damage is fading, creditors might be more open to cleaning things up early. It's like picking weeds before they take over your garden.

It also helps when you've actively corrected issues - say, you settled debts or closed accounts responsibly after those blips. Showing you've taken control builds trust that future problems won't repeat, making your letter a stronger ask.

Lastly, when you spot minor errors or borderline information that isn't a universal reporting mistake, a goodwill letter can be a smart way to request a removal courteously. It's not a dispute, just a polite ask to show goodwill, especially if the account is closed and not causing ongoing issues.

If you find yourself in one of these scenarios, a goodwill letter is worth a shot. Next, check out 'what to include in your goodwill letter' to make sure yours hits the right note. Remember, a clear, honest, and polite letter is your best bet.

What To Include In Your Goodwill Letter

Your goodwill letter needs to be clear, polite, and packed with the right info to get a shot at success. Start by stating your account details - include your full name, account number if you have it, and any identifiers that link you to the closed account. This helps the creditor pull up your records fast. Then, clearly ask for the removal of the specific negative mark on your credit report. Make your request concise and to the point.

Next, explain the situation briefly but honestly. Take responsibility where it's due, but don't over-explain or get defensive. A quick mention of any hardship or one-time mistake helps, especially if you've since fixed the issue. Outline the steps you've taken to avoid this in the future, showing you're serious about staying on track. It's about trust here.

Keep the tone professional and respectful - remember, you're asking a favor, not demanding one. Also, mention how removing the mark will positively affect your credit score or financial standing. A simple expression of gratitude at the end goes a long way.

This tight approach keeps you honest, clear, and compelling. Once you nail what to include, check out 'writing for a closed account without an account number' to make sure you've covered every base if some info is missing.

Writing For A Closed Account Without An Account Number

Writing a goodwill letter for a closed account without an account number is tricky but doable by including plenty of identifying details. Start with your full name, date of birth, and any previous addresses linked to the account so they can zero in on your file. Next, note the creditor's name, plus approximate dates you opened and closed the account to narrow down their search.

Explain clearly that you don't have an account number but want to address the closed account. Mention any statements, emails, or other documents you have, as proof - that helps a lot. Keep your tone polite and concise, emphasizing your desire to resolve the issue or improve your credit standing.

If the creditor struggles to locate the account, be ready for follow-up calls or letters to provide more details. Sometimes, contacting customer support for guidance on their preferred information can speed things up. The more you make it easy for them, the better.

Remember, a goodwill letter without an account number relies heavily on precise identity and account details. It's less ideal but still worth a shot if you genuinely explain your situation and stay respectful. For tips on crafting your message, check 'what to include in your goodwill letter' for essentials to boost your chances.

Who To Send Your Goodwill Letter To

Send your goodwill letter primarily to the creditor who originally reported the closed account - that's the one with the power to make changes. If you spot inaccuracies instead of just seeking goodwill, address your letter directly to the credit bureaus: Equifax, Experian, or TransUnion, with proof supporting your claim.

Focus on the customer service, credit reporting, or dispute departments at the creditor, since those teams handle these requests. Often, past billing statements or the creditor's website provide the correct mailing address - don't guess. If it's a closed account with no obvious contact, call their main line to confirm.

Remember, this is about building goodwill with the right people who can actually help. For tips on locating the exact address to send your letter, check out 'finding the right address for your letter' next - it's crucial to get it in the right hands.

Finding The Right Address For Your Letter

Finding the right address for your goodwill letter matters - it's the first step to getting your message where it counts. Usually, you'll want the mailing address for the creditor's credit reporting or disputes department, not just the general customer service. Check the creditor's website - look for sections like 'contact us,' 'billing inquiries,' or 'credit reporting.' If that fails, your old billing statements might list a direct address.

Sometimes, calling the creditor's main line is your best bet. Ask specifically for the correct address or fax for goodwill letter requests concerning closed accounts. It saves you guessing and ensures your letter doesn't get lost in the shuffle. Also, keep in mind you might need to send to multiple addresses if dealing with third-party collectors or the credit bureaus.

Use this checklist for clarity:

  • Creditor's credit reporting or disputes address
  • Customer service contact to verify
  • Old billing statements for backup

Be precise. These departments handle goodwill letters differently, so send to the correct one to avoid delays.

Finding this right address sets you up for success. Miss it, and your letter could vanish into a black hole. Once you have the address nailed, check out the next section, 'who to send your goodwill letter to,' to make sure your letter lands in the right hands.

Crafting A Letter For Medical Or Hardship Reasons

When you write a goodwill letter for medical or hardship reasons, start by briefly explaining the tough situation that caused the missed payments or closed account. Keep it clear but compassionate – no need to overshare, just enough to show it's an isolated event. Next, take responsibility without excuses and explain what steps you've taken to fix things or manage your hardship better now.

Include all relevant details like your account info and dates to help the creditor locate your account quickly. Make sure to ask politely for removal of the negative mark as a goodwill gesture, emphasizing how it would help your financial recovery or credit future. A sincere tone goes a long way.

Avoid sounding demanding or blaming others; creditors want honesty and respect. Also, attach any supporting documents, like a doctor's note or hospital bill, to validate your claim. If the hardship is severe or ongoing, mention how you plan to stay current going forward.

Focus on being clear, concise, and honest. This approach shows you're serious about improving, increasing your chance they'll grant goodwill. When you're done, check out 'how to follow up after sending your letter' to keep the momentum going.

Sending A Goodwill Letter For Identity Theft Cases

When sending a goodwill letter for identity theft cases, you must clearly state that the negative mark resulted from fraudulent activity, not your actions. Include copies of a police report or the FTC identity theft report to back your claim and request removal based on those facts, making this more of a formal dispute than a typical goodwill plea. Don't just ask nicely - show proof that you're a victim.

Here's what to include:

  • Your personal details and account info, if known.
  • Clear mention the item is due to identity theft.
  • Copies of official reports (police, FTC).
  • Request for removal due to fraud, not goodwill.
  • A polite, professional tone but firm stance.

For example, you might say: "This account is the result of identity theft. I have included a police report and FTC Identity Theft Report as proof. I kindly request removal of this fraudulent entry from my credit report." Keep it concise and factual.

Finally, send this letter to the creditor or credit bureau that reported the fraudulent account. Follow up if you don't hear back within 30 days. This approach links naturally with 'how to follow up after sending your letter' - you'll want to keep the pressure friendly but firm when your credit depends on it.

5 Mistakes That Sink Goodwill Letters

Five mistakes kill goodwill letters fast. First, don't be rude or demand removal - think of a goodwill letter as a polite ask, not a threat. For example, demanding 'remove this now' kills your chances immediately. Second, always take responsibility. Saying 'I'm sorry for the late payment due to personal reasons' builds goodwill, while blaming others sounds weak and evasive. Third, avoid unclear or sloppy letters. If your request is confusing or filled with errors, the creditor won't take you seriously. Spell out details clearly: what happened, why, and how you fixed it.

Next, having multiple negative marks with the same creditor makes goodwill requests nearly impossible. If your account is a mess, your letter will get tossed. Lastly, don't just ask for a better score without a good reason. Provide context like hardship or identity theft - something that earns their sympathy or understanding. Be genuine, concise, and professional. Nail these points, and you're way ahead. For deeper details on construction, check out 'what to include in your goodwill letter.'

4 Reasons Creditors Might Say No

Creditors might say no to a goodwill letter for a few solid reasons. First, they often stick to strict policies against removing accurate, negative information - especially if they see it as a clear record of your past behavior. For example, if your late payment was legitimate, they may feel obligated to report it as is.

Second, if your payment history with them is rocky or inconsistent, your goodwill request is less likely to work. It's like trying to ask for mercy when you've repeatedly missed payments before - they might simply not trust you to improve.

Third, if the negative mark is fresh and serious - say, a recent large missed payment - creditors usually won't budge. The impact is still current and severe, so they won't risk altering that reporting too soon.

Lastly, creditors may reject goodwill letters if they think altering your credit report would break their agreements with credit bureaus. They have legal commitments to report truthful info, so removing something cleanly reported could get them in trouble.

Understanding these reasons helps you tailor your approach - or decide when it's time to look at other strategies. For more on what might help your request, check out '5 situations when a goodwill letter works best.'

How To Follow Up After Sending Your Letter

Don't just send your goodwill letter and wait forever. Give the creditor about 30 to 45 days to respond - that's a fair window. After that, if nothing comes back, it's time to follow up. Be polite, not pushy. A quick call works, or if you prefer writing, send a brief second letter. Reference your original letter and kindly ask for an update. Here's what to keep in mind:

  • Wait 30-45 days before following up.
  • Keep your tone respectful and professional.
  • Mention specifics like the date you sent your first letter.
  • Avoid bombarding them with repeated messages.

Persistence matters, but patience wins. Don't escalate too fast; this can backfire. Remember, creditors aren't required to grant your request, so stay cool and strategic. If the follow-up goes nowhere, consider trying different contacts or revisiting your letter's content.

To really nail your approach next, check out 'what to do if your goodwill letter is ignored' - it shows options when follow-ups hit a wall.

What To Do If Your Goodwill Letter Is Ignored

If your goodwill letter gets ignored, don't assume it's game over. Creditors aren't obligated to respond, so silence happens. First, wait about 30-45 days, then send a polite follow-up letter restating your request clearly and briefly.

If that still fails, try these steps:

  • Call customer service and ask if another department or manager might review your case.
  • Verify you sent the letter to the right address or contact.
  • Consider sending a new letter with more specific details or updated hardship info.
  • Explore other credit repair tools like disputing inaccurate info or adding a consumer statement.

Remember, goodwill letters work best for isolated incidents with good payment history. If ignored, it's often about internal policies or strict creditor rules, not just your letter's quality. Keep calm, and check out 'how to follow up after sending your letter' for smart next moves. Sometimes persistence beats a single try.

Guss

Quote icon

"Thank you for the advice. I am very happy with the work you are doing. The credit people have really done an amazing job for me and my wife. I can't thank you enough for taking a special interest in our case like you have. I have received help from at least a half a dozen people over there and everyone has been so nice and helpful. You're a great company."

GUSS K. New Jersey

Get Started button